Sweeney: My choice for Revs' 2018 Defender of the Year is.... taken at Gillette Stadium (Revolution)

FOXBOROUGH -- We are just past the hour of 5 on this beautiful Sunday evening, Oct. 14, and media voting just closed for the 2018 Revolution Defender of the Year Award. Voting started just before 4 p.m. on Oct. 2 via SurveyMonkey, and my fellow Blue Level Denizens and I had five options from which to choose this year:


  • Andrew Farrell

  • Jalil Anibaba

  • Antonio Delamea

  • Claude Dielna

  • Brandon Bye


Conditions for selection are that the player must be a defender in the Revs’ back line, and that they must have played 50 percent of the Revolution’s matches up until the Sept. 29 debacle in Toronto. Media members could vote for two: a first-place pick, and a second-place pick. The winner of media voting will be announced at the season finale against Montreal on Oct. 28.


At BSJ, we work hard to be fair, and we work hard to hold players and teams accountable. In the same vein, we are also held accountable by our members.


With that being said, and in the interest of full disclosure, transparency — and really, because I want to pad my story count for the weekend — I’ve decided to come out and reveal my selections. Keep in mind that this was the first time I’ve been eligible to vote for this award, and I wanted to do things right. I wanted to make an educated decision… after all, this would either make us or break us in the eyes of Revolution supporters.


That’s why I’m here to tell you … I voted for

none of them. I decided to abstain.


And to be honest … can you blame me?


As I mentioned following the loss to Atlanta last weekend, the Revolution are guaranteed to finish below .500 for the third consecutive season, will miss the postseason for the third consecutive season following Saturday night’s 2-0 win over Orlando City, and now must limp to the finish line and head off into the offseason looking for the answers as to why this patheticness happened yet again.


(For the record: After the Revs were eliminated from playoff contention, I requested availability with the Krafts to see why three years of mediocrity is allowed. I was refused.)


And to be fair, I would come away looking like a hypocrite, wouldn’t I? After trashing this defense since April — April? Try 2015, you moron… we’re still waiting for the replacement to A.J. Soares at left back — how could I, in good conscience, vote for any of the selections the club put forth this year?


Want me to vote for Team MVP? Fine. I can do that. Want me to vote for Best Newcomer? Fine. I can do that rather easily. Hell, I'll vote for Goal of the Year.


But Defender of the Year, on an 9-12-11 team that will be without playoff soccer for the third consecutive season? Defender of the Year on a team which has yielded 51 goals, 26 since July 14?


Defense was the issue in coughing up a 2-1 lead on LA Galaxy on July 14.


Defense was the issue in the Minnesota United loss on July 18.


Defense was the issue in blowing the 3-2 lead on Orlando on Aug. 4.


Poor defense led to a pair of four-goal defeats to Montreal and Toronto.


Poor defense led to Vancouver getting back in the May 26 game.


For further evidence, here are detailed reasons why I couldn’t vote for any of the five:


Delamea:


  • Only played 22 minutes of the season opener; red carded for denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity — that wasn’t defense, that was a mugging

  • Freezing and not tracking back on Josef Martinez in the home Atlanta game

  • Handling against Philadelphia at home


Farrell:


  • Own goal against Columbus

  • Generally slow in tracking back

  • Couldn’t contain NYCFC at Yankee Stadium; slow in trying to stop NYCFC at home in March

  • Constant giveaways

  • Had a couple of good months of play, but that doesn’t outweigh any of the above


Bye:


  • Was promising at left back, but gave up a horrid goal to Aleksander Katai


Anibaba:


  • Had 27 blocks, which was an up for him, BUT…

  • Switched off on the LA throw-in which led to the match-winner on July 14

  • Slow to react on Philadelphia’s second goal on Aug. 11

  • Did not crack back fast enough on Cory Burke’s goal against Philadelphia on Aug. 25

  • Found himself bullied off the ball by Dom Dwyer in Orlando


Dielna:


  • Put the Revs down to nine men against Philadelphia in the opener

  • Generally played without tact #HandsLikeACementTruck

  • Was at the heart of the 1-0 loss to Dallas, ball-watching

  • Was at the heart of the 3-2 loss to the Galaxy, not clearing set pieces


The bad play list could go on — and on, and on, and on, and on.


It’s unfortunate that there is, in my mind, no clear-cut winner of the award this year; will there be a winner? Sure. Some may think I’m being nitpick-y about this… but can you pick a winner, and do so in good faith? I can’t.


In my opinion, they were all goats… and not the Tom Brady/David Ortiz/Ted Williams/Larry Bird/Bill Russell/Bobby Orr-type of G.O.A.T., either.


Maybe next year the defenders who are retained will work on not shutting off in critical moments during this offseason, and any defender brought to Foxborough this winter won’t get sliced to pieces by the attackers — or else I can assure you that we’ll have the same column for you 12 months hence.


(Note: BSJ soccer analyst Tom Benedetto also received a ballot; he, too, abstained.)

Loading...