Bedard: Ranking the Patriots' roster from season killers, to players on scholarship taken at BSJ Headquarters (Patriots)

(Getty Images)

As we begin the long countdown until the Sunday night opener against the Steelers (tomorrow will take forever), let's start our study of the team going right to the crux of the matter: ranking all 57 players in order, and putting them into tiers.

The overall criteria I used was value to the team, as in, if this player was out for the season, could the Patriots overcome it?

Plus, we divide the roster into several categories, including replaceables, luxury pieces, chemistry players, future prospects and those who should rent and not buy.

Let's kick this off right at the top with the four players who I see as essential to any possible Patriots' run to another Super Bowl title.

THEY'RE NOT WINNING A SUPER BOWL WITHOUT THEM

1. Tom Brady, QB: Duh. Sorry, I don't think the Patriots can pull an Eagles and win a Super Bowl with their backup. This scheme is too complicated and there's too much of a drop off (Grand Canyon) to the Jarrett Stidham.

2. Julian Edelman, WR: It's no coincidence that when Edelman has missed chunks of time (2015, '17) the Patriots have failed to win a Super Bowl. When he's been full-go in '14, '16 and '18 they have. Probably more than ever, Brady is going to need Edelman.

3. James White, RB: The Patriots are glad they've never had to see what life is like without Brady's life preserver. So good at what he does and not one else can approximate it.

4. Devin McCourty, S: People forget what a dumpster fire the Patriots were in the back end before he was moved from corner to safety. He's the one irreplaceable piece back there.

(Adam Richins for BS)


WINNING A SUPER BOWL IS GOING TO BE TOUGH WITHOUT THEM


5. Michael Bennett, DE


6. Stephon Gilmore, CB


7. Lawrence Guy, DT


8. Dont'a Hightower, LB


9. Joe Thuney, LG
Shaq Mason


10. Patrick Chung, S


11. Kyle Van Noy, OLB


12. Shaq Mason, RG


(Adam Richins for BSJ)


THIS IS PUSHING IT


13. Isaiah Wynn, LT


14. Jonathan Jones, CB


15. Jason McCourty, CB


16. Marcus Cannon, RT


17. Matthew Slater, STs
Keion
Crossen


18. JC Jackson, CB
Jason McCourty's


19. Ted Karras, C


20. Stephen Gostkowski, K


21. Jermaine Eluemunor, G/T


(Adam Richins for BSJ)


GOOD PLAYER, BUT YOU'RE REPLACEABLE


22. Sony Michel, RB:


23. Terrence Brooks, S/STs


24. Danny Shelton, NT


25. James Develin, FB


26. Chase Winovich, OLB
Rob
Ninkovich


27. Phillip Dorsett, WR


28. Matt LaCosse, TE


29. Jarrett Stidham, QB


30. Ben Watson, TE (susp.)
Alge
Crumpler


31. Josh Gordon, WR


32. Jake Bailey, P


33. Joe Cardona, LS


(Adam Richins for BSJ)


LUXURY PIECES


34. Jamie Collins, LB
Patrick Chung,


35. Brandon Bolden, RB/STs


36. John Simon, OLB


37. Demaryius Thomas, WR


38. Shilique Calhoun, OLB


(Adam Richins for BSJ)


YOU'RE HERE FOR CHEMISTRY PURPOSES


39. Duron Harmon, S
Patrick Chung


40. Elandon Roberts, LB


41. Rex Burkhead, RB


42. Adam Butler, DT


43. Obi Melifonwu, S/STs
football player


44. Deatrich Wise Jr., DE


45. Nate Ebner, STs


(Adam Richins for BSJ)


THE FUTURE IS YOURS


46. N'Keal Harry, WR (IR)


47. Joejuan Williams, CB


48. Ja'Whaun Bentley, LB


49. Byron Cowart, DT


50. Ryan Izzo, TE
Lance Kendricks


51. Jakobi Meyers, WR


52. Damien Harris, RB


(Adam Richins for BSJ)


RENT, DON'T BUY


53. Gunner Olszewski, WR/STs


54. James Ferentz, C/G
Russ
Bodine


55. Korey Cunningham, OT


56. Lance Kendricks, TE (susp.)


57. Cam Meredith, WR (PUP)

Loading...
Loading...