Bergeron Line vs. MacKinnon line: Who has the edge in Wednesday's bout? taken at BSJ Headquarters (Bruins)

With four Selke Trophies already on his loaded resume, Patrice Bergeron is no stranger in going toe-to-toe with some of the most dynamic lines in the NHL — with the B’s center often tasked with taking draws against the likes of Connor McDavid, Sidney Crosby, John Tavares and Auston Matthews while shutting down some potent forward trios.

It’s that two-way ability that has lifted Boston’s top line of Bergeron, Brad Marchand and David Pastrnak into the conversation as the best forward group in the league, with the trio just as prone to lighting up an opposing defense as it is stymieing scoring chances down the other end of the ice.

Wednesday will mark the latest challenge for the Bergeron line — with the group poised to go up against an Avalanche trio that’s doing its best to steal the spotlight from the Boston’s top forwards.

Anchored at the pivot by Nathan MacKinnon, Colorado’s top line has the speed and size to find twine early and often, and they have the numbers to prove it.

So far this season, the Avs’ line of MacKinnon, Gabriel Landeskog and Mikko Rantanen have tallied 28 goals and 69 points through 17 games — with the Bergeron line following suit with 31 goals and 68 points.

Wednesday’s tilt at the Pepsi Center will feature plenty of firepower, with all six forwards ranking in the top 25 in scoring in the NHL — headlined by Rantanen (26 points - tied for 1st) and Bergeron (25 points - 3rd).

"They're an amazing line, they're playing with amazing pace and tempo, but also making great plays," Bergeron said Tuesday. "Obviously they have a good team over there, playing hard. We saw that last year against them. They're young with lots of energy, so it's going to be a tough matchup, for sure.”

He added: "They seem to be making a lot of plays in tight, a lot of bang-bang, tic-tac-toes, and stuff like that. “Obviously they get open for one another and seem to find each other pretty well.”

With both lines expected to earn heavy minutes against one another on Wednesday, which trio has the edge when it comes to staking the claim as the top triumvirate in the league?



Tale of the tape

While both the Bergeron and MacKinnon line have similar production in terms of scoring, both groups measure out very differently when it comes to size, especially off the wing.

Next to McDavid and speedsters like Dylan Larkin and Carl Hagelin, there may not be a fastest skater in the NHL than MacKinnon, who can explode through the middle of the ice and catching opposing blue liners flat-footed very easily.

But MacKinnon also benefits from some big bodies to his left and right, with Rantanen and Landeskog measuring out at 6-foot-4 and 6-foot-1, respectively. With their size, both wingers can muck up the slot with ease, while the 22-year-old Rantanen has made strides in his play on the boards, especially in terms of retrieving pucks and feeding it back out to MacKinnon.

While Marchand is more than capable of creating separation and winning puck battles along the boards, Bruce Cassidy did note that size is obviously an advantage for Colorado, with Marchand and Pastrnak measuring out at 5-foot-9 and 6-foot-0, respectively.

“They’re bigger than ours,” Cassidy said of the MacKinnon line. “I think they can all makes plays and score like our guys. I think our guys are a little more experienced and quicker. I shouldn’t say that — they can all skate very well. The element — I’d say that ours is a little more dynamic and theirs is bigger.

"Our trio isn’t as big, but they have plenty of courage that makes up for that. Those guys have plenty of size and they make enough good plays.”

Of course, any highlight reel involving Marchand proves that size isn’t the ultimate determinant in terms of who wins a puck battle along the boards or in the corner, with the pesky winger using his strength to maintain possession of the puck, especially while shooting through the neutral zone.

Much like Marchand, Pastrnak has made strides in his game thanks in large part to his added strength both on and off the puck — with Cassidy noting that the 22-year-old winger has elevated his play to another level thanks to his ability to rifle home shots from outside of his usual comfort area, while also creating space for himself with ease.

Sure, Pastrnak still has the wheels and skills with the puck on his stick to make defensemen and goalies look foolish off the rush, but the winger’s new willingness to open up space, fight off opposing skaters and create open ice for Bergeron and Marchand to cause havoc down low has added a new element to the line.




“I think they try to lean on him,” Cassidy said of opposing team’s strategies in terms of containing Pastrnak. “But he’s become physically more mature over the years. That’s a difficult task, a lot more than it used to be. They’ve to really think about defending his shot. Taking that away. He’s worked on that part of it. Gets it off in a hurry, finds that soft ice. So that’s probably how they’ll have to adjust to defending him. Which isn’t easy.


“Because if you start leaking away from the net to where he likes to hang out, then all of the sudden, Marchy is inside or Bergy is inside and that’s what makes the line good. ...But that’s probably how teams talk about Pasta. Along with the obvious with his speed and one-on-one, that hasn’t changed over the four years, but I think his shot and his strength on the puck have.”


Play away from the puck


The case could be made that the Bergeron line is slumping a bit this season in terms of their play away from the puck — with the trio out on the ice for nine goals against during over 187 minutes of five-on-five (5v5) play this season. (Stats via
)


After all, it took until the start of January last season for Boston’s top line to be tagged with a goal against at 5v5 — after over 220 minutes of TOI together.


(I mostly kid about the slumping aspect — that 5v5 stat from last year is absolutely bananas and there was no way that line was going to recreate that kind of statistic.)


But while the Bergeron line has been prone to surrendering more goals than usual, the Black and Gold have largely held the edge in terms of possession and scoring chances when that group is out on the ice.


During 5v5 play this year, the Bruins have led in attempts, 207-152, and outshot opponents, 104-87, when the Bergeron line is out on the ice.


Among forward lines that have logged at least 150 minutes of TOI together,  the Bergeron trio rank fourth in Corsi For Percentage at 57.66 — with the Montreal line of
Brendan Gallagher, Phillip Danault
and
Tomas Tatar
leading in that category with a CF% of 66.4.


In terms of Corsi, the MacKinnon line ranks 11th in that group with a CF% of 47.02, with the Avalanche out-attempted, 231-205, and outshot, 132-121, during the 237 minutes of 5v5 ice time when Colorado’s top line is skating.


From this perspective, it looks as though the Bergeron line has the slight edge over the MacKinnon line in terms of the unit’s overall 200-foot game, but make no mistake — the MacKinnon line is far from a liability out on the ice.


Will Wednesday’s matchup be the final determinant as to which line has bragging rights as the top group in the league? Of course not. But it should make for one entertaining hockey game.


“It's hard to pick between the two lines in terms of who's better, what would you prefer,” Cassidy said. “I know from my point of view, I love our top line. They've done everything we've asked. I'm sure (Avs coach) Jared (Bednar) would say the same.


"It will be good if they matched up,” Cassidy continued. “(Bednar will) control that matchup. That will be up to him. At the end of the day, that might settle the argument for a night, anyway. I'm sure both lines will play very good no matter who they're matched up against. It should be good hockey.”

Loading...